Abuse Law – Case Law Update – Application to set aside settlement deeds - Jens v The Society of Jesus in Australia [2024] VSC 329 

In the recent matter of Jens v The Society of Jesus in Australia [2024] VSC 329, the plaintiff, Peter Damien Jens, brought proceedings against the defendant, The Society of Jesus in Australia Limited, in relation to childhood abuse suffered by the plaintiff whilst a student by a priest.

The plaintiff alleged sexual abuse by a priest, Father Bradford, on two occasions while he was a student boarder at Xavier College in Melbourne in 1968 and 1970. The plaintiff alleges the following (at [18] to [20]):

In or around 1968, while lying in his bed in a Xavier College dormitory, Fr Bradford put his hands under the plaintiff’s pyjama top, touched his stomach, moved his hands down into the plaintiff’s pyjama pants and fondled his genitals…

In or around 1970, Bradford took the plaintiff into his bedroom at Xavier College. The bedroom contained a desk and chairs. The plaintiff was wearing summer pyjama shorts. Bradford sat on a chair behind his desk, and directed the plaintiff to sit in another chair near the rear corner of the desk. Bradford moved close to the plaintiff, leant over and put his hands on the plaintiff’s legs. Bradford then moved his hands up the plaintiff’s legs and inside his pyjama shorts, then fondled the plaintiff’s genitals…

The plaintiff did not attempt to report the abuse to the police until 2016. He told a police member of the Sano Taskforce what had happened to him in general terms. The plaintiff ultimately did not make a formal statement, citing a lack of confidence in authorities given his previous experiences.

In this proceeding, the plaintiff claims damages from the defendant, The Society of Jesus in Australia. However, the plaintiff had previously released the defendant from claims relevant to the abuse. The release was recorded in a settlement deed on 22 August 2011, and a variation deed on 9 December 2016. The plaintiff sought to claim additional damages which required an order that the two earlier settlement deeds be set aside.

The defendant said that the plaintiff’s settlement deeds were not eligible to be set aside. The defendant further submitted that, alternatively, that the plaintiff’s settlement deeds are not eligible to be set aside insofar as they relate to economic loss.

At [90] The Court provided as follows:

I adopt the Court of Appeal’s summary in Trustees of the Christian Brothers v DZY (a pseudonym) [2024] VSCA 73:

In a series of enactments, the Victorian Parliament moved to address problems facing those who claim to have suffered personal injuries as a result of physical or sexual abuse while a minor (‘child abuse’), perpetrated on them long ago by persons acting under the auspices of an unincorporated association. Relevantly, those enactments were to the following effect:

(a) from 1 July 2015, to remove any limitation period for an action founded on the personal injury to a person resulting from child abuse;

(b) from 1 July 2018, to require the nomination or appointment of an entity to act as the proper defendant on behalf of an unincorporated non-government organisation in child abuse cases and bear the liability of the unincorporated organisation — in other words, to overcome the Ellis defence; and

(c) from 18 September 2019, to provide that an action for personal injury resulting from child abuse may be brought on a previously settled cause of action (as defined) by allowing a plaintiff to apply to the court to set aside settlement agreements on the basis that it is ‘just and reasonable’ to do so.

At [91], the Court further provided as follows:

Here, the settlement deed was made before the legislative amendments. The parties executed the variation deed after the removal of the limitation defence, but before the removal of the Ellis defence. However, as discussed below, it is evident from the variation deed, the correspondence leading up to it, and the advice each party received from their solicitors, that the parties regarded themselves as bound by the earlier settlement deed. There is no evidence that the removal of the limitation period had any impact on the variation deed.

In its analysis, the Court provided as follows (at [121], [123], and [125]):

Firstly, the plaintiff has deposed that he had knowledge of the barriers and they impacted his decision to seek compensation directly from the defendant and accept the settlement sum…

Secondly, Mr Lombard’s evidence is that he told the plaintiff that there were legal difficulties with a claim against the defendant. Mr Lombard deposes that he was aware of the legal barriers. Although he cannot recall the precise conversation with the plaintiff, he would have said something concerning them…

Thirdly, as I stated earlier, it is common ground that neither party raised the legal barriers in their discussions with the other. There is no evidence to refute the plaintiff’s belief that the legal barriers existed when he entered into the settlement deed. I decline to draw an inference that he was aware that the defendant was not relying upon the legal barriers when he was negotiating the settlement deed because the defendant had publicly stated it would not and did not refer to the barriers in the settlement discussions. Drawing this inference is contrary to the plaintiff’s evidence above.

The issue of potential prejudice was also discussed. In its analysis of this, the Court provided as follows (at [184]):

Save for the legal barriers, the plaintiff had a good prospect of success if he proceeded to trial when he entered into the settlement deed in 2011. The defendant admits some of the 1968 abuse allegation and says it was reported on or about 30 July 2008. The plaintiff’s uncontradicted evidence is that the 1970 abuse occurred.

Ultimately, on 19 June 2024, the Victorian Supreme Court ordered that the plaintiff’s two previous settlement deeds be set aside, having regard to, what the Court described as, legal barriers at the time, being a time limitation barrier and the legal identity barrier. The Court did not separate out the settlement in relation to economic loss, based on the evidence. It was held that it could not be inferred that the plaintiff had elected not to pursue economic loss in the earlier settlements (at [264]).

We are specialist abuse lawyers and can help you receive acknowledgement, meaningful apology and financial resolution from those institutions and systems of power that failed to protect you from harm. If you would like advice in relation to a childhood or adult sexual, physical and/or psychological/emotional abuse claim in any jurisdiction in Australia, please reach out to Littles Lawyers today. 

Further Abuse Law information and case law updates can be found on our website.

If you have any queries regarding the article, please contact via Free Claim Checker or email us.