Abuse Law Update: Special Leave Granted in DZY v Christian Brothers
In the matter of DZY (A Pseudonym) v Trustees of the Christian Brothers [2024] HCASL 245, the plaintiff (DZY, a pseudonym) commenced court proceedings in negligence and vicarious liability against the defendant, the Trustees of the Christian Brothers (“the Christian Brothers”), seeking damages for the injury, loss and damages, including economic loss, as a result of alleged abuse suffered by the plaintiff whilst he was a student at St Alipius Boys School in Ballarat between 1964 and 1968.
The Christian Brothers filed a defence in this proceeding in which they do not admit the abuse occurred, however, do admit that one of the two alleged perpetrators, Brother Best, was criminally convicted of one count of indecent assault in 2017 in relation to the plaintiff in these proceedings. Furthermore, the Christian Brothers relied on the terms of two previous settlement agreements as a bar to the plaintiff’s current proceeding.
The first Deed was entered in December 2012 for $80,000 inclusive of costs and the second, without undoing the first, in 2015 for $20,000 inclusive of costs. Both Deeds acknowledged that the plaintiff did not allege that he suffered economic loss and made no demand for such loss as part of those settlements.
The plaintiff filed an application pursuant to the Limitation of Actions Act 1958 (Vic) to set aside the two previous settlement agreements to the extent that they are a bar to his current proceeding.
Ultimately, on 21 March 2023, the Court held that it was just and reasonable to set aside the whole of the previous settlement agreements, saying at [124]:
The plaintiff’s instructions not to pursue his economic loss claim should be viewed against all of the circumstances. In my view it is not possible to find that the limitations and the Ellis defence issues had no material influence on the plaintiff’s decision not to pursue his economic loss claim.
The Christian Brothers had not resisted the initial application by the plaintiff to set aside earlier settlement agreements insofar as the plaintiff wished to pursue his claim for general damages. However, the Christian Brothers sought to maintain the effect of the deeds insofar as they barred any claim for economic loss. After he decision was handed down on 21 March 2023, the Christian Brothers applied for leave to appeal the primary court’s order, confined to its operation in respect of the plaintiff’s claim for damages for economic loss.
On 23 April 2024, the Victorian Supreme Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, and held at [150] as follows:
Still, there is no positive finding that DZY’s decision not to pursue an economic loss claim was materially influenced by the existence and potential impact of the limitations and Ellis defences. Instead, a completely unrelated issue was the chief explanation for that decision. In that context, DZY’s feeling that he had no choice, the exclusion of a lack of supporting evidence for the claim as an explanation for the decision and the lack of prejudice to the Christian Brothers do not make it just and reasonable to set aside the deeds insofar as they barred pursuit of the economic loss claim…. Our reasons for not finding that it is just and reasonable to set aside the deeds, insofar as they barred the economic loss claim, cover the substance of the remaining grounds.
The plaintiff then sought special leave to appeal from the whole of the judgement of the Victorian Court of Appeal, allowing an appeal against the judgement of the Victorian Supreme Court.
On 5 September 2024, special leave to appeal was granted by the High Court of Australia, but is limited to proposed grounds 1 and 3(b) of the special leave application. The High Court provided that the application otherwise has insufficient prospects of success.
We are specialist abuse lawyers and can help you receive acknowledgement, meaningful apology and financial resolution from those institutions and systems of power that failed to protect you from harm. If you would like advice in relation to a childhood or adult sexual, physical and/or psychological/emotional abuse claim in any jurisdiction in Australia, please reach out to Littles Lawyers today.
Further Abuse Law information and case law updates can be found on our website.
If you have any queries regarding the article, please contact via Free Claim Checker or email us.