In the recent matter of TG v MM [2024] NSWSC 730, the plaintiff sought orders from the New South Wales Supreme Court that the plaintiff’s name and identity be suppressed.

A suppression order, or a non-disclosure order, necessarily detracts from the principle of open justice, which is one of the most fundamental aspects of the system of justice in Australia.

The application was made in proceedings brought by the plaintiff against the defendant for damages alleged to have been caused by a medical procedure performed by the defendant in 2012.

The defendant has filed a defence dated 22 April 2024. In the defence, the defendant does not admit liability. The defendant does not oppose the suppression application before the Court.

The Court held that it was unnecessary to set out all the circumstances described in the evidence before the Court on the application, but the following summary was included in the reasons (at [4]):

  1. the circumstances of the procedure are likely to be regarded by patients as confidential and are in fact regarded by the plaintiff as confidential;
  2. in the past, the plaintiff has been exposed to violence from a number of people;
  3. the plaintiff is afraid to have attention drawn to the circumstances of the claim;
  4. there has been media interest in circumstances not unrelated to the plaintiff’s claim;
  5. the plaintiff works in an occupation not unrelated to the claim; and
  6. the medical condition of the plaintiff, alleged not to be unrelated to the claim, includes both physical and important mental health considerations.

At [5], the New South Wales Supreme Court provided as follows:

On the evidence, I accept that there is a real prospect that the plaintiff will not proceed with the claim if it will result in attention being drawn to the plaintiff.

At [18], the New South Wales Supreme Court further provided as follows:

I accept that there is some prospect that attention being drawn to the plaintiff may result in harm to the plaintiff, especially having regard to the past exposure to violence from a number of people and the important mental health issues addressed in the evidence.

Ultimately, on 13 June 2024, the New South Wales Supreme Court made an order pursuant to the Court Suppression and Non-Publication Orders Act 2010, that the name and identity of the plaintiff be suppressed until 2044, except as may be necessary for the proper conduct of these proceedings, upon the ground that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice and is necessary to protect the safety of the plaintiff.

The Court ordered that until further order, the plaintiff in these proceedings:

  1. be known as “TG”;
  2. be described in all pleadings and all documents filed and served in the proceedings as “TG”; and
  3. except as may be necessary for the proper conduct of the proceedings, be only referred to as “TG”.

The Court further ordered that the parties’ costs of this notice of motion be reserved.

Our team are specialist personal injury lawyers who can assist you with your claim on a ‘No Win No Fee’ basis. If you would like advice in relation to a personal injury claim, including a medical negligence claim, please reach out to Littles Lawyers today.

Further blogs in relation to medical negligence and personal injury claims can be found on our website.

If you have any queries regarding the article, please contact via Free Claim Checker or email us.